Features Comparison

  Home  Previous  Next

Monitoring Studio vs BMC Performance Manager for Servers

The table below recapitulates the monitoring features usually required in order to monitor a custom application or any IT component for which no standard monitoring solution already exists. The table shows whether a feature is available in each solution and its capability if present.

Features comparison between BMC Performance Manager for Servers and Monitoring Studio

Feature

BMC Performance
Manager for Servers

Monitoring Studio

Process monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOn

Filesystem monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOff

Folder monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOn

Log file parsing

starOnstarOnstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

SNMP polling

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOff

SNMP trap listening

starOnstarOnstarOff

WBEM polling

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

HTTP requests

starOnstarOnstarOff

JMX polling

starOnstarOnstarOn

SQL queries

starOnstarOnstarOn

Windows EventLogs parsing

starOnstarOnstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Windows Performance Counters

starOnstarOnstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Commands execution and analysis

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

String searches

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Multi-line parsing

starOnstarOnstarOff

XML parsing

starOnstarOnstarOff

Numeric value extraction

starOnstarOnstarOn

Per-application grouping

starOnstarOnstarOff

Recovery Actions

starOnstarOnstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Custom monitoring deployment

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Feature not present
starOnstarOffstarOffBasic
starOnstarOnstarOffGood
starOnstarOnstarOnAdvanced

As the table clearly shows, Monitoring Studio provides a much more complete feature set regarding standard needs in order to monitor a custom application. On the other hand, the purpose of the BMC Performance Manager for Servers solution is to ensure that the underlying operating system (Windows, UNIX, Linux or OpenVMS) is functioning properly and is not meant to provide a simple way to monitor anything running on this operating system. What BMC Performance Manager for Servers does offer however is the ability to develop a custom monitoring solution using PSL.
This is a completely different task that is covered in the Monitoring Studio vs. Development of a Custom Solution section.

Monitoring Studio vs. Development of a Custom Solution

The table below recapitulates the monitoring features usually required in order to monitor a custom application or any IT component for which no standard monitoring solution already exist. The table shows whether a feature is available in each solution and its capability if present.

Features comparison between a custom KM and Monitoring Studio

Feature

Development
of a custom KM

Monitoring Studio

Process monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Filesystem monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

Folder monitoring

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Log file parsing

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

SNMP polling

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

SNMP trap listening

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

WBEM polling

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

HTTP requests

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

JMX polling

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

SQL queries

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Windows EventLogs parsing

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Windows Performance Counters

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Commands execution and analysis

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

String searches

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Multi-line parsing

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

XML parsing

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

Numeric value extraction

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Per-application grouping

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOff

Recovery Actions

starOnstarOnstarOn

starOnstarOnstarOn

Custom monitoring deployment

starOnstarOffstarOff

starOnstarOnstarOn

Feature not present
starOnstarOffstarOffBasic
starOnstarOnstarOffGood
starOnstarOnstarOnAdvanced

The above table indicates that every monitoring feature in BMC Performance Manager Monitoring Studio can be present and more powerful in a custom KM…as long as you accept all the hidden costs, time taken and resource allocation required for custom development, the possibilities are endless. From a pure features point of view and without taking into account the time taken to develop it, a custom KM could certainly have more (or less) capabilities than Monitoring Studio KM. A custom KM is only what you make it. The fact that one custom KM with so many features may take 1 year to develop is not shown in this table.